ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE: CAN YOUR LAWYER SPILL YOUR SECRETS?
Attorney-Client Privilege: How to Keep Communications With Your Attorney Confidential
The attorney-client privilege allows clients (and even potential clients) to talk with their attorneys freely with the knowledge that their communications will stay confidential. Trust and open communication is critical when clients are working with an attorney. Oftentimes, the client needs to share sensitive or complicated information with their attorney so the attorney can help them. And the last thing most clients want if for their lawyer to spill their secrets! I had the chance to talk with CBS News about the attorney-client privilege and share some mistakes that people unintentionally make that prevent the privilege from applying as well as some of the exceptions to the privilege. Below is an excerpt of my interview.
Legal expert Danielle Mayoras talks with CBS News about attorney-client privilege
Rachelle: Welcome back to CBS News Detroit at noon. When hiring an attorney you often expose vulnerable parts of your life, but should you be worried about sharing those secrets? Let’s go ahead and bring in our legal expert Danielle Mayoras. Danielle thanks for being on with us. What is attorney client privilege? I feel like you hear about it in all the shows and movies, but we may not know the nitty-gritty details.
When does the attorney-client privilege start?
Danielle: It actually is something that begins between the attorney and client as soon as you have that first communication with the attorney…whether it’s a meeting [or] a phone call. And what’s important to know– it actually starts before you even hire the attorney. And this is for all areas of law from estate planning to criminal law and everything in between.
Why is the attorney-client privilege so important?
Rachelle: Why is that in place? Why is it so important?
Danielle: We need people to trust us as attorneys because the goal is for the client to be able to share whatever they need to. And a lot of times, as you can imagine, it’s personal information that is tough to share [and] sometimes really sensitive or complicated. And they need to have that trust between themselves and the attorney to feel comfortable. So knowing the attorney can’t share that with anyone else, which is essentially what attorney-client privilege does, makes people feel a lot more comfortable. It’s kind of like going to the doctor…how you need to share everything with the doctor.
Are your meetings with your lawyer still confidential if you bring a friend or family member? What about emails?
Rachelle: And it’s great to know that that happens from the initial outreach–the email, the phone call, whatever it may be as you’re shopping around and figuring out who you want to work with. What if you bring a friend a family member with you to meet with your attorney? What are the circumstances there?
Danielle: You definitely want to think about that because what’s interesting is when you bring someone else into a meeting with the attorney, the attorney-client privilege isn’t there anymore. Because now instead of just you and the attorney, there’s a third party involved. And this is not just meetings with your attorney, but this is even emails with your attorney. So if you’re emailing your attorney and including a friend or family member on the email, you may want to think twice about that.
Rachelle: So even the things the two of you one-on-one…well I guess it would be two-on-one, those are not confidential because that third party is there?
Danielle: Exactly. Everything else is confidential. People make that mistake unknowingly. I think so it often happens where you’re including other people because you want the support of a friend or a family member, but you don’t stop to think that if something changes and they need to testify or something happens, there’s not that attorney-client privilege for that particular meeting or that email.
Does the attorney-client privilege end when you pass away?
Rachelle: And what happens if let’s say you pass away? Is that still honored beyond your death?
Danielle: It is. It’s interesting because it’s not only during your lifetime. If I’m working with a client on estate planning, I can’t then go tell all their business when they pass away, which is good because no client wants that. But the personal representative of the estate… he privilege transfers to them. So whoever you choose to act as your personal representative they are allowed to communicate with the attorney and get any background information that they need. So you really want to think about who you’re choosing for your personal representative.
What are some exceptions to the attorney-client privilege? When are your communications with your attorney not confidential?
Rachelle: Okay I do have to ask this…this just popped into my mind…are there exceptions? Because so often with let’s say an HR department or something, you may feel is normally in confidence, there are exceptions for violence or you know thoughts of self harm. Is there anything where that privilege?
Danielle: Absolutely! In law there’s always exceptions. One thing is if you’ve committed a past crime and you’re telling your attorney, it’s actually okay. But if there’s a future crime, there is not privilege for that thank goodness. We don’t want people to tell their attorneys they are going to commit a crime and have that covered by the privilege. The attorney would need to obviously share that with the police. And then there’s other times, like if I’m working with a husband and wife and doing estate planning and then down the road they go through a divorce. Anything said between the two of them, there’s no privilege to keep [those things confidential in their divorce]. And there’s also court exceptions, but overall the privilege is pretty sturdy. So while there are exceptions ,you should definitely feel confident and comfortable having that trust with your attorney and knowing that. They do need to know all the details so that they can properly help you.
How can you contact Danielle for legal help or for more legal tips and information?
You can contact Danielle for legal help here. For more legal tips and information, you can find Danielle’s website here and her book, Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!, here.
Danielle Mayoras is a legal expert, author, and attorney. She is the co-author of Trial & Heirs: Famous Fortune Fights!, a legal media expert, and keynote speaker. You can find her on Instagram, YouTube, and LinkedIn. For all of the latest legal news and helpful legal tips, advice and information, be sure to check out her blog.
DISCLAIMER: Nothing should be relied on as legal advice. The information contained herein does not create an attorney/client relationship. The information posted is intended for general information purposes only. Laws vary state by state. Anyone seeking legal advice for a specific situation should consult a qualified attorney or similar qualified professional in the appropriate state.

